Following U.S news media coverage of the Burgas, Bulgaria bombing, one would conclude that the Hezbollah provenance of the attack can be determined from recent alleged Hezbollah terrorist plotting against Israelis in Cyprus and elsewhere. TheÂ New York TimesÂ quotedanonymous U.S. officials saying that the Burgas attack bears â€śall the hallmarksâ€ť of â€śthe Hezbollah plots, including the arrest in Cyprus earlier this month of a suspected operative on the suspicion of scheming to kill Israeli tourists.â€ť
So an arrest of a â€śsuspectedâ€ť Hezbollah operative who is â€śsuspectedâ€ť of a plan to kill Israeli tourists is the equivalent of an actual terrorist attack that has killed Israeli tourists? Bibi NetanyahuÂ talked about the caseÂ on Fox News Sunday as though the Lebanese man arrested in Cyprus had done everything that was done in Burgas except actually detonate the bomb. TheÂ Israeli pressÂ has echoed this theme.
But as IÂ reportedÂ last week, the Cyprus case is far murkier than Netanyahu and those U.S. officials have been suggesting. A senior Cypriot officialÂ told Reuters, â€śIt is not clear what, or whether, there was a target in Cyprus.â€ť Furthermore, the Cypriot investigators believe the Lebanese man they suspected of planning to harm Israeli tourists wasÂ acting alone, which doesnâ€™t make it sound like a Hezbollah operation at all. Perhaps most significant of all, there has been no sign of a bomb or even of materials with which to make a bomb in conjunction with the Lebanese detainee. The Cypriot government hasÂ not yet decidedÂ whether there is enough evidence to prosecute the man on any violation of Cypriot laws.
The need for skepticism surrounding the Cyprus arrest applies even more strongly to the arrest in Bangkok January 12 of another Lebanese with a Swedish passport. The arrest came after what wasdescribedÂ by the Thai Deputy Prime Minister as â€śweeks of coordination with Israel.â€ť According to the official, the Israeli government had told Thai officials that â€śa group of people who appear to be from the Lebanese group Hezbollahâ€ť were planning to strike tourist sites in Bangkok in mid-January, presumably to harm Israeli tourists.
The Lebanese who was arrested was charged with possession of ammonium nitrate and urea fertilizer, which are potential bomb-making materials. But none of the other necessary components for bomb-making, such as fuses and timing devicesÂ were ever found. The former police chief, who is now the Secretary General of the Thai National Security CouncilÂ expressed doubtÂ that the man was actually a terrorist.
Given the fact that the Israelis were at the time planning theÂ assassinationÂ of Iranian scientist Mostafa Ahmadi-Roshan in early to mid-January, the Israeli tale of a massive terrorist threat coming in mid-January, which was first passed on to Thai authoritiesÂ on December 22, was extremely convenient in terms ofÂ distracting attention from the inevitable negative press accompanying the Israeli terrorist action.
While the Obama administration and the Israeli government have pointed to these murky allegations in Cyprus and Bangkok as relevant to Burgas, it has exhibited no apparent interest in the historical record ofactualÂ suicide bombings against Israeli tourists.
The reason, apparently, is that all of the terrorist attacks that fit that description have been claimed by Al Qaeda or an affiliate.
The first suicide bombing against Israeli tourists wasÂ an Al Qaeda attackÂ in Mombasa, Kenya, in November 2002. That operation involved an effort to shoot down an Israeli passenger jet as it took off from Mombasaâ€™s airport, using shoulder-launched anti-aircraft missiles, and then the triple suicide car bombing of an Israeli-owned hotel in Mombasa.Fortunately, the missile missed the aircraft, but the suicide bombing killed three Israeli tourists and 10 Kenyans.
The small number of Israeli deaths did accurately reflect Al Qaedaâ€™s intentions. In claiming responsibility for the Mombasa attacks, Al QaedaÂ proclaimedÂ that it was targeting â€śThe Christian-Jewish allianceâ€ť and promised future and more lethal attacks on Jews around the world.
In October 2004, three suicide bombers detonated a truck bomb and car bombs at the Hilton Hotel in Taba and two other Red Sea resorts that were favorites of Israeli tourists in Egypt andÂ most of the 34 dead were indeed Israelis.Â The Abdullah Azzam Brigades, an affiliate of Al Qaeda, took responsibility for the attack.Â The organizationÂ saidÂ the attacks were intended to â€śpurify the land of Taba from the dirt and corruption of the grandchildren of monkeys and pigs.â€ť
In July 2005, three more terrorist attacks by suicide bombs killed at least 88 people at a shopping area and hotel packed with tourists, including Israelis, in the Egyptian Red Sea resort city of Sharm el Sheik. The Abdullah Azzam Brigades againÂ claimed responsibilityÂ for what it called an attack â€śon the Crusaders, Zionists and the renegade Egyptian regime.â€ť
The Abdullah Azzam Brigades organization wasÂ designatedÂ by the State Department as a Foreign Terrorist Organization on May 24 of this year. Strangely, the designation ignored the history of the organization in suicide attacks on Israeli tourists in Egypt and said it was established only in 2009. But it did point out that the organization has bases in Lebanon which have launched rocket attacks on population centers in northern Israel, as well as an Arabian Peninsula branch which has declared its interest in kidnapping U.S. and British tourists.
Even if the U.S. national security state does not wish to acknowledge that the Burgas bombing fits the profile of an Al Qaeda terrorist operation rather than one by Hezbollah, there is no excuse for the U.S. news media failure to report that inconvenient truth.
*A version of this article appeared onÂ www.antiwar.com