The Secret Memo That Explains Why Obama Can Kill Americans
OCT 3 2011, 9:10 AM ET 1024
Isn’t that interesting? Months ago, the Obama Administration revealed that it would target al-Awlaki. It even managed to wriggle out of a lawsuit filed by his father to prevent the assassination. But the actual legal reasoning the Department of Justice used to authorize the strike? It’s secret. Classified. Information that the public isn’t permitted to read, mull over, or challenge.
Why? What justification can there be for President Obama and his lawyers to keep secret what they’re asserting is a matter of sound law? This isn’t a military secret. It isn’t an instance of protecting CIA field assets, or shielding a domestic vulnerability to terrorism from public view. This is an analysis of the power that the Constitution and Congress’ post September 11 authorization of military force gives the executive branch. This is a president exploiting official secrecy so that he can claim legal justification for his actions without having to expose his specific reasoning to scrutiny. As the Post put it, “The administration officials refused to disclose the exact legal analysis used to authorize targeting Aulaqi, or how they considered any Fifth Amendment right to due process.”
Obama hasn’t just set a new precedent about killing Americans without due process. He has done so in a way that deliberately shields from public view the precise nature of the important precedent he has set. It’s time for the president who promised to create “a White House that’s more transparent and accountable than anything we’ve seen before” to release the DOJ memo. As David Shiplerwrites, “The legal questions are far from clearcut, and the country needs to have this difficult discussion.” And then there’s the fact that “a good many Obama supporters thought that secret legal opinions by the Justice Department — rationalizing torture and domestic military arrests, for example — had gone out the door along with the Bush administration,” he adds. “But now comes a momentous change in policy with serious implications for the Constitution’s restraint on executive power, and Obama refuses to allow his lawyers’ arguments to be laid out on the table for the American public to examine.” What doesn’t he want to get out?
Image credit: Reuters
Related articles
- Obama has crossed a line and gone way past GWB (bellalu0.wordpress.com)
- Aulaqi’s Killing Sanctioned by Secret U.S. Memo (themoderatevoice.com)
- Us Secret Memo (maboulette.wordpress.com)
- Did Obama Just Assassinate A U.S. Citizen? Aulaqi Killing Raises Questions Over Presidential Powers (jonathanturley.org)
- Secret U.S. memo sanctioned killing of Aulaqi – The Washington Post (policyabcs.wordpress.com)
- Anwar al-Aulaqi Apparently Killed by Drone in Yemen (volokh.com)
- Anwar al-Aulaqi Killed (davidscommonplacebook.wordpress.com)
- Was Obama’s kill order an assassination? (ikners.com)
- The Death Of Anwar Al-Awlaki And The Imperial Presidency (outsidethebeltway.com)
- Secret US memo sanctioned killing of Aulaqi – Washington Post (news.google.com)
- Obama’s Dangerous al-Awlaki Precedent (alternet.org)
- Justice Department Memo Approved Killing of Awlaki (newser.com)
- Herman Cain in May: Don’t Kill Anwar al-Awlaki (Get out the Popcorn) (gunnyg.wordpress.com)
- Anwar al-Awlaki killed in Yemen – live coverage (guardian.co.uk)
- Dorian de Wind: The Anwar al-Awlaki Killing: Cheney’s Bluster vs. Obama’s Deeds (huffingtonpost.com)
